More categories
More categories

Smart Shopper is reader supported. When you shop our picks, we may receive a commission.

Shop the best dog collars for big and small pooches

We’ve selected the best-rated dog collars based on comfort, features and durability.

Published Mar 08, 2024
4 min. reading time
Image of woman with dog and two dog collars

Apart from indicating ownership, a dog collar can also be used for a variety of reasons like for training purposes and to attach​​ dog harnesses. Because it’s worn 24/7, it’s important to find a collar that’s comfortable and durable to sustain your dog’s daily routine.

From Tractor Supply dog collars to the best dog collars for puppies, we’ve searched for the best dog collar brands to bring you different options that would suit your pet most. Continue reading to find out more.

Read more: Keep your dogs rested with our list of dog beds

Dark maroon Carhartt dog collar
Best for big dogs
Carhartt Adjustable Nylon Duck Dog Collar
Colorful plaid flannel dog collar
Best for puppies
Sorbet Plaid Flannel Dog Collar
$35 at The Foggy Dog
Brown Rolled Leather Dog Collar
Best for small dogs
CollarDirect Rolled Leather Dog Collar
$16.85 at Chewy
SportDOG FieldTrainer SD 425 X-Series Remote Dog Training Collar
Best for training
SportDOG FieldTrainer SD 425 X-Series Remote Dog Training Collar

Best for big dogs

Pros & Cons
  • Collar doesn’t get soaked

  • Reflective watermark

  • Fits dogs of all life stages

  • Durable belt buckle

  • Reports of clasp not gripping as tight

This Carhartt Adjustable Nylon Duck Dog Collar is a good dog collar if you have a big dog. It’s made with durable nylon webbing and features Rain Defender technology that prevents the collar from getting soaked.

Available in sizes M and L, it’s designed with a reflective Carharrt watermark that becomes visible in low-light settings. It also has a slotted metal D-ring that’s suitable for holding dog tags.

Best for puppies

Pros & Cons
  • Personalized buckle

  • Gentle on puppies with allergies

  • Specific cleaning method

There are plenty of reasons why this Sorbet Plaid Flannel Dog Collar is the best collar for a puppy. We love the colorful flannel design made from soft natural fabric that’s gentle on puppies with allergies or chafing. 

You’ll also get to personalize your collar by imprinting your contact information like a phone number and address in case your pup goes for a stroll too far away from home. When it comes to keeping it clean, simply hand wash or machine wash in a cold setting. 

Welcoming a new four-legged buddy into your home soon? This is definitely the best puppy collar you can find.

Best for small dogs

Pros & Cons
  • Multiple colors and sizes

  • High-quality leather craftsmanship

  • Non-allergic

  • Doesn’t come with a dog tag.

This is one of the best dog collars for small breeds. This Rolled Leather Dog Collar from CollarDirect is designed with soft leather and durable metal hardware and it’s compatible with name tags and dog leashes.  

Available in a variety of colors and sizes, it suits all types of dogs from extra small to large breeds.

You’ll love that it’s soft to the touch and non-allergic, making it perfect for canines with sensitive skin.

Pros & Cons
  • Withstands heavy-duty activities

  • Comes with rechargeable battery

  • Submersible up to 25 feet

  • Not suitable for small dogs

Training working dogs or preparing them for hunting? This SportDOG FieldTrainer SD 425 X-Series Remote Dog Training Collar is one of our picks of the best dog collars. With up to 21 levels of static stimulation, you’ll get to choose from a range of tones and vibrations to help develop your canine’s skills.

Equipped with an easy-to-use remote, you’ll get to focus on your dog than on your equipment. It’s also waterproof and submersible up to 25 feet. 

Got more than one pooch? You’ll be able to communicate with up to three dogs with the purchase of Add-A-Dog collars.

Best martingale style collar

Pros & Cons
  • Easy-to-attach buckle

  • Reflective webbing

  • Comes with a travel pouch

  • Auto dual voltage

  • Not washing machine-safe

This Martingale Collar makes the perfect accessory for escape artist dogs that have a habit of backing out of traditional collars. With a variety of sizes to choose from, the collar also features a separate ID tag attachment point, a silicone tag silencer and a comfortable webbing.

To keep the collar tight without clinching your pet’s neck, simply adjust the collar for the right fit. When it’s time to wash, hand wash the buckle with normal detergent.

Best anti-bark collar

Pros & Cons
  • Waterproof

  • Adjustable collar

  • Won’t hurt your dog

  • Collar may go off from the barks of other nearby dogs

If your canine barks a little too much, get them the FAFAFROG Rechargeable Smart Collar to prevent them from yapping incessantly. With four working modes and five adjustable sensitivity levels, you can easily control how much resistance you need to train your dog without hurting them. 

The collar takes two hours to charge and can be worn for up to 15 days. It’s also IP67 waterproof so you can enjoy a day at the beach without worrying about damaging the collar. Thanks to its adjustability,  it will fit your dog comfortably even as they grow and it’s why we recommend this as one of the best dog collars to control barking.

Best for tracking

Pros & Cons
  • Suitable for small to big dogs

  • Made from 100% genuine leather

  • Airtag not included

As a pet parent, your biggest fear would likely be having your furbabies go missing. Thankfully, with this CollarDirect Airtag Dog Collar, you won’t have to worry about that. 

Designed with a double snap and small opening to ensure secure placement of your Apple Airtag, you can easily track your dog’s location through your phone.

When it comes to comfort, the collar is made from 100% genuine leather and has a sturdy one-click button that stops your dog from chaffing and wiggling out from their collar.

What is the best material for a dog collar?

Depending on the size and type of dog you have, you’ll need a collar that is made from durable material to sustain daily wear and tear. You’ll also need it to be comfortable for your dog to wear. Materials like nylon and leather are great for dog collars as they are soft and durable enough to withstand your dog’s daily activities.

The best dog collars revealed

We’ve reviewed all the dog collars on our list carefully and we stand by all of our options. However, if you’re looking for more help in making a decision, we consider these two to be the best dog collars that will suit most dogs:

Did you like this article? For more great deals and shopping ideas, find us now on your favorite social networks: Facebook, Instagram and Pinterest!

Prices updated on 03/08/2024. We are not responsible for any changes to the prices mentioned above.

Afina Najib Professional Headshot
Written by
Afina Najib

A journalism graduate from Curtin University, Afina Najib specializes in writing tech, finance, automotive and wellness content. Now residing in Kuala Lumpur, Afina spends her weekends hitting the gym or watching Formula 1 races.

Specialized topics