More categories
More categories

Smart Shopper is reader supported. When you shop our picks, we may receive a commission.

Looking for an eye cream to reduce dark circles? Shop 8 of the best

Say goodbye to pesky dark under-eye circles thanks to these top creams, each of which boast powerful formulas and proven results.

Published Jul 25, 2023
5 min. reading time
five eye creams from The Inkey List, Kiehl's, OLEHENRIKSEN, Clinique and Caudalie

Are dark circles casting a shadow on your confidence?

Don’t panic.

A solution is on its way.

We’ve scoured the web in search of the best eye creams for dark circles and have hand-selected our top picks.

Read on to discover the creams that will brighten your under-eye area, reduce puffiness and, in some cases, even offer hydration, firming and plumping effects.

Read more: Find the best vitamin C serums for glowing skin

The 8 best eye creams for dark circles

bottle of The INKEY List Retinol Eye Cream
Our favorite retinol option
The INKEY List Retinol Eye Cream
$12.99 at Sephora
a bottle of Caudalie Vinoperfect Dark Circle Brightening Eye Cream
Our favorite brightening pick
Caudalie Vinoperfect Dark Circle Brightening Eye Cream
$55 at Sephora
a bottle of OLEHENRIKSEN Banana Bright 15% Vitamin C Dark Spot Serum
Our favorite serum for dark spots
OLEHENRIKSEN Banana Bright 15% Vitamin C Dark Spot Serum
$71 at Sephora
a bottle of Paula’s Choice C5 Super Boost Eye Cream
Best lightweight cream
Paula’s Choice C5 Super Boost Eye Cream
$39 at Paula's Choice

Our favorite retinol option

Pros & Cons
  • Powerful anti-aging benefits 

  • Brightens and refreshes under-eyes 

  • Suitable for all skin types

  • Potential sensitivity to retinol Not suited to day-time use

Carefully formulated to be gentle yet effective, INKEY’s Retinol Eye Cream is suitable for all skin types, including sensitive skin.

Featuring superstar ingredient, retinol, which is known for its exceptional anti-aging properties, what truly sets this eye cream apart from competitors is its slow-release nature.

Rather than your skin being hit with a powerful dose of retinol in one go, thanks to its Vitalease technology, this retinoid formula is released slowly over a period of time to reduce the likelihood of skin irritation, whilst ensuring effective absorption.

The inclusion of squalane helps to further moisturize and hydrate, while peptides work to improve skin elasticity and reduce puffiness.

For best results, apply before bed and allow these incredible ingredients to work their magic whilst you sleep.

Our favorite brightening pick

Pros & Cons
  • Effectively addresses dryness, dullness and dark circles 

  • Users say it is convenient to wear under makeup 

  • Fragrance, paraben and sulfate-free

  • Results may not be immediately obvious 

  • Pricey

This eye cream is infused with a game-changing cocktail of botanical extracts that work in harmony to deliver exceptional results.

Featuring viniferine, niacinamide and caffeine, this product not only effectively brightens and refreshes your under-eye skin, but it also targets uneven skin tones and offers intensive moisture to those with dry skin concerns.

Commitment to natural and clean beauty, this Caudalie eye cream is formulated without harsh chemicals, parabens or sulfates, making it both a gentle and indulgent option for anyone looking for an effective lightening cream.

Our favorite serum for dark spots

Pros & Cons
  • Evens out skin tone and hyperpigmentation 

  • Illuminates and smooths skin 

  • Leaves skin feeling plump and supple

  • Potential sensitivity to vitamin C

  • One of the pricier options

This serum is like a little bottle of sunshine for your skin.

Packed with 15% vitamin C — a powerhouse ingredient known for its ability to fade dark spots and hyperpigmentation — you’ll be rocking that ‘lit-from-within’ glow in no time.

This product is infused with banana powder-inspired pigments, which illuminate the skin and blur imperfections. Meanwhile, polyhydroxy acids provide gentle exfoliation, and hyaluronic acid hydrates and plumps, leaving the area beneath your eyes feeling soft, supple, and oh-so-smooth.

As if that’s not enough to sway you, this cream also boasts a delightful citrus-based scent, so every application will remind you of a wee tropical vacation.

Best lightweight cream

Pros & Cons
  • Lightweight and fast-absorbing formula 

  • Reduces the appearance of dark circles 

  • Targets dullness and firms skin 

  • Possibility of skin sensitivity or irritation

Designed to target multiple concerns, this eye cream truly shows those dark, puffy eyes who’s boss.

With a potent dose of vitamin C, this cream not only brightens, soothes and firms, but the addition of antioxidants also acts as a shield, protecting your skin from environmental stressors.

This formula is also lightweight and fast-absorbing, so you won’t be left with any heavy, greasy sensations after use. Bonus.

Our favorite option for dry skin

Pros & Cons
  • Appropriate for dry, sensitive skin

  • Provides a burst of hydration 

  • Reduces under-eye puffiness

  • No extensive anti-aging benefits Some users report skin sensitivity

Boasting a 4.6-star average rating from over 2,500 reviews, All About Eyes is one of the best-selling eye creams for those experiencing dryness.

Designed to glide on your skin and provide a burst of moisture that instantly refreshes and plumps up the area around the eyes, this formula is incredibly hydrating.

In fact, some users even say it has been useful in treating concerns such as eczema and claim it does not tighten skin following application.

From a brand known for creating quality products, this cream’s gentle and effective formula ensures everyone can enjoy the benefits of brighter, vibrant eyes.

Our favorite hydrating option

Pros & Cons
  • Formulated with natural avocado oil 

  • Enriched with essential fatty acids and vitamins

  • Rich and creamy texture

  • Some users found the ingredients separated  

  • High price point

In need of some serious hydration? Then this is the cream for you.

Infused with the goodness of creamy avocado oil, it provides an intense boost of hydration that leaves your under-eye area radiant and moisturized.

What’s more, it soothes and calms the skin whilst working to reduce the appearance of puffiness and dark circles.

Oh, and did we mention the rich and creamy texture melts effortlessly into the skin, making it a joy to apply? Treat yourself, immediately.

Our favorite serum for aging skin

Pros & Cons
  • Unique cooling metal applicator

  • Firms and hydrates under-eye skin 

  • Convenient, travel-friendly packaging

  • Not budget-friendly 

  • May dispense too much product at once

Inspired by the power of cryotherapy, this eye cream is designed to refresh and awaken the area around your eyes. The unique cooling applicator provides a soothing sensation as it glides over your skin, working to reduce the appearance of fine lines and eye wrinkles.

Featuring an innovative formula of peptides, vitamin A, vitamin C, caffeine and botanical extracts that brighten, firm and hydrate skin, we think this Charlotte Tilbury option sounds like a wee bottle of icy-cool magic.

Our favorite drugstore eye cream

Pros & Cons
  • Affordable and effective 

  • Dermatologist-tested and formulated

  • Packed with nourishing ingredients

  • Product sensitivity reported from some users 

  • More basic packaging

Despite being from a drugstore and featuring the lowest price point in our round-up, CeraVe’s formula well and truly earn its spot on our best eye creams list.

It contains ceramides, hyaluronic acid and niacinamide which work together to hydrate and nourish the eye area, resulting in a more even complexion.

Tested by dermatologists, it is also fragrance-free and non-irritating, making it well-suited to those with sensitive skin.

An effective, budget-friendly option that delivers high-quality results? Sign us up.

FAQs

Which eye creams are the best for dark circles? 

While each of the above options is great for targeting dark circles, two products, in particular, stood out to us as top contenders: 

  • The INKEY List Retinol Eye Cream: In our opinion, this product takes the crown for the best cream. Its highly effective formula combines retinol and Squalane to work wonders on those pesky dark circles. 

  • CeraVe Eye Cream Repair: If you’re looking for a more budget-friendly option, CeraVe is the perfect investment. This cream combats multiple under-eye concerns and has been formulated specifically for sensitive skin.


Prices updated on 07/25/2023. We are not responsible for any changes to the prices mentioned above.

Jada Bowman Professional Headshot
Written by
Jada Bowman

Jada Bowman is an Atlanta-based freelance writer. Through her work, Jada aims to make the lives of her readers better by guiding them toward the most exceptional products and lifestyle choices.

Specialized topics
Bathroom