Find the best toaster oven to complete your kitchen

Toaster ovens are not just for toasting bread. Today, these kitchen workhorses have multiple features that can do everything from baking cookies to roasting chicken. They also have innovative designs that take up less counter space than before. But there are so many questions to answer while researching this purchase. Should you choose a regular toaster over a toaster oven? What are the disadvantages of a toaster oven? How do I decide on the best toaster oven for my home?

We’ve searched countless toaster oven reviews to come up with a list of some of the best ovens on the market. We have recommendations for every type of appliance, from smart toaster ovens to mini options. Some models can fit your entire dinner, and others are best for that personal-size pizza.

Whether you’re looking for a toaster oven large enough to cook an entire dinner or a space-saving option to fit a personal pizza, you’ll find something to fit your needs. Whatever you’re looking for, you will find it among the toaster ovens we tested. Read on to compare prices and features to choose the perfect appliance.

Read more: Shop from our list of espresso machines for a fresh brew daily

Find the best toaster oven for you

Best overall

Ninja - Foodi Convection Toaster Oven

Jump to details

$189.99 at Best Buy

Top mini-sized pick

Hamilton Beach Easy Reach 1200 W 4-Slice Toaster Oven with Roll-Top Door

Jump to details

$64.99 at Amazon

Best large option

Oster Extra Large French Door Air Fryer Toaster Oven

Jump to details

$179 at Walmart

Top budget pick

BLACK+DECKER 4 Slice Toaster Oven

Jump to details

$34.99 at Target

Show 3 more

Best overall

Ninja - Foodi Convection Toaster Oven

You save $100 (34.48%)

$189.99$289.99

$189.99 at Best Buy

Specifications

• Cook settings: 11

• Programmable: Yes

• Dimensions: 8.15 x 15.33 x 20.21 in. (H x W x D)

Pros & Cons

• Dual heat technology for fast, even cooking 

• Maximum versatility with 11 ways to cook 

• Energy efficient

• Some reports of electrical issues

• One of the larger, more expensive models on our list

If you’re looking for a higher-end toaster oven with all the bells and whistles, this oven by Ninja could be a good choice. It ranks as the best toaster oven overall on our list, and with good reason. There are 11 different cooking functions, including bake, broil, toast  and air fry. It has dual heat technology, which can reach 500 degrees in minutes.

With an extra - large capacity, you can cook for the whole family and give your full-size oven a rest. The digital screen is easy to read, and the oven flips up to store flush against your backsplash to save counter space.

Plus, it cooks 65% faster for those busy nights when you need dinner on the table quickly. The toaster oven comes with everything you need no matter how you cook, including an air fry basket, nonstick sear plate, wire rack and a removable crumb tray.

Top mini-sized pick

Hamilton Beach Easy Reach 1200 W 4-Slice Toaster Oven with Roll-Top Door

$64.99

$64.99 at Amazon

Specifications

• Cook settings: 3

• Programmable: No

• Dimensions: 10.5 x 17.4 x 13.6 in. (H x W x D)

Pros & Cons

• Compact and simple to use

• Removable, roll-up door

• Auto shutoff

• Less versatile than other options, with only three functions

• Lower temperature range

For people with smaller kitchens, this Hamilton Beach countertop toaster oven is our top mini-sized pick, ranking high on our list of best toaster ovens. It has a removable, roll-up  door for easy cleaning and access to food, and a maximum temperature of 450 degrees.

This small toaster oven is surprisingly spacious, easily fitting four slices of bread or a nine-inch pizza. With simple manual controls, it’s a snap to use, though there’s not a lot of variety with only three cook functions.

With a 30-minute timer and auto-shutoff,  you won’t have to worry about the mini toaster oven being on all day. This Hamilton Beach model comes with the accessories you need, including a bake pan, oven rack and a slide-out crumb tray.

Best large option

Oster Extra Large French Door Air Fryer Toaster Oven

$179

$179 at Walmart

Specifications

• Cook settings: 6

• Programmable: No

• Dimensions: 15.1 x 23.9 x 20.3 in. (H x W x D)

Pros & Cons

• Large capacity

• Auto shutoff

• Faster preheat

• Some issues with the French doors

• No replacement accessories

If you have a big family or just like to cook a lot of food, check out this large toaster oven from  Oster. It can fit a family-size chicken and has three rack positions to fit an entire dinner. Its fast, preheat technology not only lowers cooking time but also uses 50% less energy than other toaster ovens.

Convenient French doors open with one pull for ease, revealing an extra-large interior. Plus, it comes with six preset functions such as air fry, bake and turbo convection. Separate controls for cooking, temperature and time, ensure you won’t get confused. The toaster oven also comes with several accessories, including an air fry rack, baking pan and removable crumb tray.

Top budget pick

BLACK+DECKER 4 Slice Toaster Oven

You save $5 (12.50%)

$34.99$39.99

$34.99 at Target

Specifications

• Cook settings: 4

• Programmable: No

• Dimensions: 8.7 x 15.5 x 11.18 in. (H x W x D)

Pros & Cons

• Low price

• Easy to use

• Compact

• Not great for cooking larger items

• Some complain that it runs too hot

If you are looking for a toaster oven that is easy on the bank account, check out this budget option from BLACK + DECKER . It comes with EvenToast Technology, which evenly spreads the heat when you toast bread, so there’s no more burning one side or the other. There are four cook settings to keep things simple, with bake, broil, toast and keep warm.

With its space-saving design, this model is the best small toaster oven on our list. It comes with a baking pan, rack and removable crumb tray. Additionally, all these accessories are dishwasher-safe. Sometimes you just need simple and durable when it comes to toaster ovens, and BLACK + DECKER has that covered.

Best smart toaster

Breville - Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro Convection Toaster/Pizza Oven

You save $50 (11.11%)

$399.95$449.95

$399.95 at Best Buy

Specifications

• Cook settings: 13

• Programmable: Yes

• Dimensions: 12.8 x 21.4 x 17.2 in.  (H x W x D)

Pros & Cons

• Backlit LCD control panel

• Sleek stainless steel

• Tons of uses in one appliance

• Expensive

• A bit complicated to use

Take the work out of cooking with this smart toaster oven by Breville. It is one of the top-rated toaster ovens on our list, with 4.8 out of 5 stars. It has a whopping 13 settings, including slow cook, air fry, toast, bake, roast and more. Not to mention, the oven looks sleek with its stainless steel exterior and LCD control panels.

The interior is large enough to fit a 13-inch nonstick sheet pan. The toaster is equipped with Element IQ technology, which sends power where it is most needed. This, combined with digital temperature control, keeps your pizza and fries from burning. It also comes with an enamel bake pan, two heavy-duty oven racks, a mesh basket and a roast rack.

Top pick with convection

Cuisinart 1500 W 6-Slice Convection Toaster Oven

$129.95

$129.95 at The Home Depot

Specifications

• Cook settings: 5

• Programmable: No

• Dimensions: 16.75 x 19.75 x 11 in. (H x W x D)

Pros & Cons

• Easy to use

• Preheats quickly

• Precise toast shade control

• Some reported issues with the timer

• May broil too fast and burn food

This medium-sized model from Cuisinart is our choice for the best convection toaster oven. You can cook everything from chicken to pizza with the convection bake mode. The convection toaster oven preheats fast and has precise toast shade control, so you won’t burn the bread or chocolate chip cookies.

The heating elements bake, broil or toast, and it’s easy to use with its simple controls. You’ll also get everything you need to use the oven, like a baking tray, rack and a booklet with instructions and recipes.

Best air fryer toaster

Breville - the Smart Oven Air Fryer

You save $30 (7.90%)

$349.95$379.95

$349.95 at Best Buy

Specifications

• Cook settings: 11

• Programmable: Yes

• Dimensions: 10.9 x 18.9 x 15.9 in. (H x W x D)

Pros & Cons

• Precise, even cooking

• Super versatile

• Reduces cooking time

• Some reported issues with the door

• High price point

Get an appliance that does it all with this Breville smart oven air fryer. Breville is known for creating high-end smart appliances, and this model is no different. It has 11 cook settings to choose from, including slow cooking, baking, roasting and warming. This is an excellent air fryer toaster oven, with a dual-speed convection fan that reduces cook time by up to 30%. 

Get precise, even cooking, whether you’re roasting a chicken or baking a frozen pizza. The LCD display shows the cooking temperature and the amount of time on the timer. The toaster oven comes loaded with accessories, including an air fry basket, roast pan, 13-inch pizza pan, wire rack and broil rack.

Do  I really need a toaster oven?

You might wonder if a toaster oven is necessary when you have a full-size oven. Toaster ovens can come in handy, and here are a few reasons you should consider adding one to your kitchen: 

• Great for saving energy: Do you really need to turn on the oven just to reheat that casserole or make something small? If you have a toaster oven, you don’t. They’re smart options that can help conserve energy and keep your kitchen cooler. 

• Safer for kids: If you’re a family that likes to cook together, using a toaster oven can be  safer for the kiddos than cooking in a large oven. You can let them be more involved in dinner prep or baking without worrying about them getting burned.

• More versatile than a toaster: You might think you don’t need a toaster oven because you already have a toaster. But, toaster ovens can do so much more, like roast a chicken or turn out perfectly  melted cheese on top of pizza.

• Heats up faster: Go with the toaster oven if you need to reheat or cook something quickly. It heats up in no time and cooks faster, too.

• Like having an extra oven: If you’re putting together a whole feast and your large oven is already full, a toaster oven can help you get everything done by providing additional cooking space.

Which toaster oven gets our vote?

Toaster ovens  come in a variety of sizes and have different features to fit any need, whether you’re living alone or have a full house to feed. But if you can’t decide which one to add to your kitchen, these two are our favorites:

• Hamilton Beach Easy Reach 1200 W 4-Slice Toaster Oven with Roll-Top Door: Sometimes you just need something simple to help with quick dinners. This one is affordable, compact and reliably gets the job done.  It’s a great choice for folks cooking individual meals or just enough for two.

• Breville - the Smart Oven Air Fryer: The toaster oven reviews on this model don’t lie. People love this multi-function appliance for its versatility. With 11 cook settings, programmable functions and a powerful fan, you’ll reduce the amount of time you spend cooking.  

Want to upgrade your home with a new toaster oven for the kitchen? Try out one of our recommendations, to see if any get your vote for the best toaster oven 2023.

Did you like this article? For more great deals and shopping ideas, find us now on your favorite social networks: Facebook, Instagram and Pinterest!

Prices updated on 10/16/2023. We are not responsible for any changes to the prices mentioned above.